Saturday, February 2, 2008

#4: How I Met I Your Seinfeld

When I watch SEINFELD I often think about the sitcom, HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER. These two shows have several similarities, on and off the screen. HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER was created by Craig Thomas and Carter Bays and they drew from their friendship in creating the show. The main character, Ted, is based on Bays and two other characters, Marshall and Lily are based on Thomas and his wife. This is similar to SEINFELD in the sense that the creators also based characters off their own lives as well.

HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER has many characters that play parallel roles to the characters in SEINFELD. Ted resembles Jerry as he is the main character and has his act together more than anyone else on the show. Robin is similar to Elaine because although she has a stable career, she just can never seem to have a steady relationship. She will date people but then always find a reason to break up with them. Barney can be compared to both George and Kramer. He is like George because he is manipulative, a liar, and very self-centered. But, he is also comparable to Kramer because he is eccentric and viewers never know what he is going to do next.

Although HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER may be a bit more confusing to jump in the middle of, both shows are self-reflexive. There are several flashbacks in most episodes and there are some reflexive comments that are thrown in as well. The show does not really try to teach many moral lessons, it is just a narrative sitcom about a man looking back and telling his kids how he met their mother.

2 comments:

Kelli Marshall said...

Thanks, Jenna. Could you elaborate a bit more on this section? "Although HOW I MET YOUR MOTHER may be a bit more confusing to jump in the middle of, both shows are self-reflexive. There are several flashbacks in most episodes and there are some reflexive comments that are thrown in as well." Why would it be "confusing to jump in the middle of" this show? And what "reflexive comments are you referring to"? Thanks.

Jenna Hayes said...

A new viewer jumping in the middle of a season might not understand what has been going on in the show up to that point. For example, season two is all about Marshall and Lily breaking off their engagement and how that is effecting all the rest of the characters. A new viewer would not know what was going on or why them breaking up was such a big deal. But because the show does have so many flashbacks, it allows the viewer to catch up and maybe better understand the story line. The show is reflexive in the sense that this group of friends has certain "inside jokes" that they share with the viewers. For example, Barney thinks that every time the group goes out they should dress up nicely, so when they are getting ready he always tells the guys to "suit up!" This line is used in many episodes and one might not get the joke if they did not know the meaning.